Case list info

[Doyle Srader <DSRADER@UGA.CC.UGA.EDU>]

Michigan state KW (USC RR)
hold in court case that innsurance industry should pay for pollution
occurring in 1970-1986
adv 1 toxic waste- people die
adv 2 china- they model and we and others invest in their new found
insurance industry.  prevents fractionalization of china and war

Negative arguments:

Central Oklahoma
CP: Exclude capital gains tax
Oil price DA
Trade DA
vs. Warming: Oil, Trade, Federalism

George Mason
CP: States
Federalism DA
Small business confidence DA
vs. Lead abatement: Abatement is extratopical, CWC, States/federalism,
small business confidence

Kansas
Topicality-Must be command and control
Locals Counterplan-Devolve to local governments solves better
Adversity DA-- Regs on business force them to stop cooperation on Global
warming initiatives which kills millions
Environmental Racism DA- You entrench the government based approach to
environmental racism which is bad, need external movts. to solve
vs. Lead abatement: All of the above, plus Clinton/bond market.

Miami, FL
vs. Warming: Delay CP, Russian oil, CO2 agriculture

UMKC
vs. Warming: Ice age, trade, oil, tibetan cooling, CO2 turns

Wayne State
K Power: Foucault
vs. Lead abatement: Abatement is extratopical, inflation, Power K

One thing I've tried to persuade the Dawgs to do is turn in judge reports,
relaying comments judges made about their perspective on debate. Only a
couple have come in, and some were unhelpful <"he yelled at us for
undercovering a case turn in 2AR">, but here are the ones that I think are
informative. It'd be nice if others could post such reports as well,
keeping in mind that the purpose of this is to capture adaptation-friendly
comments, rather than to relay people's rants or debaters' caricatures of
judge incompetence. In other words, if you do post such info, please screen
it for relevance and flammability.

Parcher noted that he was a conservative topicality judge <meaning he
didn't think much was topical this year>. Kentucky I

Zompetti noted his predisposition against the Clinton disadvantage because
of myriad problems with the internal links and uniqueness. Kentucky III

Doyle Srader
University of Georgia
<706> 548-9938

" ... which just shows you can have an M.A. and a Ph.D and still
  fall for the same old B.S."
     Cecil Adams, RETURN OF THE STRAIGHT DOPE, p. 62

---

• Prev by Date: No Subject
• Next by Date: USAFA Results to GregUSAFA results to Greg
• Prev by thread: (no subject)
• Next by thread: USAFA Results to GregUSAFA results to Greg
• Index(es):
  • Date
  • Thread
  • Author

---

Archive created by Jonathan Stanton (jonathan@cs.jhu.edu)
Return to main CEDA-L Archive Page