SEE NO, HEAR NO, PERM NO EVIL

["Jason Cruce Trice" <tricejas@student.msu.edu>]

MONKEYS--AN ENDANGERED SPECIES IN CEDA THEORY

THERE ARE SEVERAL LEGITIMATE PERM STANDARDS:

1.  TEXTUAL COMBINATIONS--DEFINITIONALLY, PERMS ARE COMBINATIONS OF THE PLAN
(ALL OF IT) AND ANY OR ALL OF THE COUNTERPLAN.  NO ADDITIONS TO THE TEXTS ARE
ALLOWED.  WE FEEL CONFIDENT EVEN KLEMZ WOULD AGREE WITH OUR INTERPRETATION OF
TEXTUAL STANDARDS.

2.  PERMS MUST BE WRITTEN--THIS AVOIDS SHIFTS OF ARGUMENTS IN REBUTTALS

3.  PERMS AREN'T ADVOCATED--THIS PREVENTS DEVEREAUX TYPE 2AR'S THAT ADVOCATE
THE PERM WITHOUT PRIOR NOTICE.

WE FEEL THAT THESE TYPE OF STANDARDS MAKE PERM DEBATES MUCH SIMPLER AS WELL AS
PROVIDE THE JUDGE SOME DIRECTION AS HOW TO EVALUATE THEM.

---

Follow-Ups:

• Re: SEE NO, HEAR NO, PERM NO EVIL
• From: Klemz Aaron <aak322s@nic.smsu.edu>

---

• Prev by Date: THE SKY IS FALLING--OR ARE THOSE COCONUTS
• Next by Date: GOT THE MONKEY BY THE TAIL
• Prev by thread: Re: THE SKY IS FALLING--OR ARE THOSE COCONUTS
• Next by thread: Re: SEE NO, HEAR NO, PERM NO EVIL
• Index(es):
  • Date
  • Thread
  • Author

---

Archive created by Jonathan Stanton (jonathan@cs.jhu.edu)
Return to main CEDA-L Archive Page